Ad Widget

Collapse

Zabbix Sucks! Sorry, I'm moving on...

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • jmay
    Junior Member
    • Oct 2014
    • 8

    #1

    Zabbix Sucks! Sorry, I'm moving on...

    Reasons why it sucks... (in no particular order)

    Reason 1) Installed it on a brand new server running ubuntu 14. Nothing else installed. After 2 weeks of testing it crashes about every 2-3 days with a message that the zabbix server is no longer running. Restarting the server and I'm good for a few more days. Bad sign!

    Reason 1.5) I'm only monitoring about 300 devices at this point with about a half dozen items being checked every 5 minutes. Required server performance is 5 per second. I think the first computer I ever built could have handled that. The ultimate goal would have been to monitor 4000 devices. If I'm having trouble with a fraction of my network I can't afford to jack with it to get the entire thing in there.

    Reason 2) The method to change host names to an snmp value does not work. I followed the instructions but they remain named by IP addresses. I found a forum post with someone having the same issue and the response he got was and I quote "that's weird".

    Reason 3) SNMP values are not searchable. I need the ability to find devices by different oid's and I cannot do that with this software. Inventory items would have worked but some genius decided to code this feature as disabled by default and the mass update does not work. When choosing to mass update the changes are not applied.

    Reason 4) The documentation sucks!

    Reason 5) And this might be petty but a new user posts a question to this forum and has to wait several days for it to be checked by a moderator before posted?? What if I had a real emergency that I needed help with? I've belonged to hundreds of forums over the years and have never come across anything like that.

    Reason 6) You get what you pay for I guess.

    Thanks for listening to my rant.. It was nice meeting the 2 or 3 of you that actually responded to my questions. I'm now off to look for some other crappy software that fits the "free" budget my boss gave me. Wish me luck, or don't... I don't care.
    Last edited by jmay; 05-11-2014, 18:02.
  • aib
    Senior Member
    • Jan 2014
    • 1615

    #2
    Try SpiceWorks
    http://www.spiceworks.com/free-snmp-...ment-software/

    In free version you will have a lot of advertisement, but it still useful.
    Sincerely yours,
    Aleksey

    Comment

    • kloczek
      Senior Member
      • Jun 2006
      • 1771

      #3
      Originally posted by jmay
      Reasons why it sucks... (in no particular order)

      Reason 1) Installed it on a brand new server running ubuntu 14. Nothing else installed. After 2 weeks of testing it crashes about every 2-3 days with a message that the zabbix server is no longer running. Restarting the server and I'm good for a few more days. Bad sign!
      Even worse sign is that seems you did not check zabbix server logs.
      I'm not Debian user and have no idea which one version you have been using.
      Did you check server logs after crash? What was in the logs?

      Reason 1.5) I'm only monitoring about 300 devices at this point with about a half dozen items being checked every 5 minutes. Required server performance is 5 per second. I think the first computer I ever built could have handled that. The ultimate goal would have been to monitor 4000 devices. If I'm having trouble with a fraction of my network I can't afford to jack with it to get the entire thing in there.
      And above does not contain any useful details which can be used on diagnose your issue.

      Reason 2) The method to change host names to an snmp value does not work. I followed the instructions but they remain named by IP addresses. I found a forum post with someone having the same issue and the response he got was and I quote "that's weird".
      Are you monitoring something only over SNMP?

      Reason 3) SNMP values are not searchable. I need the ability to find devices by different oid's and I cannot do that with this software. Inventory items would have worked but some genius decided to code this feature as disabled by default and the mass update does not work. When choosing to mass update the changes are not applied.
      Sorry are taking about different OIDs or different content read from OIDs?

      Reason 4) The documentation sucks!
      IMO bollocks. Zabbix documentation is one of the best documentations across all OSS projects (is not perfect but definitely is way above avenge).
      Please show example(s) where something is not enough documented.

      Reason 5) And this might be petty but a new user posts a question to this forum and has to wait several days for it to be checked by a moderator before posted?? What if I had a real emergency that I needed help with? I've belonged to hundreds of forums over the years and have never come across anything like that.
      This is public forum. Not supported officially with some SLAs by zabbix developers. As far as I know there is no moderation here.

      Reason 6) You get what you pay for I guess.

      Thanks for listening to my rant.. It was nice meeting the 2 or 3 of you that actually responded to my questions. I'm now off to look for some other crappy software that fits the "free" budget my boss gave me. Wish me luck, or don't... I don't care.
      As long as it is only rant without proper set of facts which can be analyzed .. sorry just try to read your posts and try to stand on other side and try ask yourself "do I have from this guy enough details to understand his issue(s)?"
      http://uk.linkedin.com/pub/tomasz-k%...zko/6/940/430/
      https://kloczek.wordpress.com/
      zapish - Zabbix API SHell binding https://github.com/kloczek/zapish
      My zabbix templates https://github.com/kloczek/zabbix-templates

      Comment

      • jan.garaj
        Senior Member
        Zabbix Certified Specialist
        • Jan 2010
        • 506

        #4
        IMHO you didn't use the right tool for your task. But that's not a problem of Zabbix.

        If you talk "Zabbix sucks", then I talk "Monitoring sucks" - visit
        https://github.com/monitoringsucks/tool-repos and choose some better monitoring tool. I'll be happy, if you share your choice.
        Devops Monitoring Expert advice: Dockerize/automate/monitor all the things.
        My DevOps stack: Docker / Kubernetes / Mesos / ECS / Terraform / Elasticsearch / Zabbix / Grafana / Puppet / Ansible / Vagrant

        Comment

        • tchjts1
          Senior Member
          • May 2008
          • 1605

          #5
          Originally posted by jmay

          Reason 5) And this might be petty but a new user posts a question to this forum and has to wait several days for it to be checked by a moderator before posted?? What if I had a real emergency that I needed help with? I've belonged to hundreds of forums over the years and have never come across anything like that.
          Now you are exaggerating. I am a forum Admin and a moderator here.

          I can tell you how and why we do certain things here. We had a huge issue with spam accounts on this forum, and also spam getting posted into the forums. I personally deleted over 80,000 spam accounts created by SpamBots. This took months of work to do on my part, and I am a volunteer.

          To also curtail the posting of spam into the forums, the first 3 posts from a new user must be approved by a moderator. After that, they are free to post as they like. It would be a very rare occasion that any of those first 3 posts has to wait more than 24 hours. And more than likely they are approved within just a few hours.

          In your scenario about an emergency - If you are running a production Zabbix setup which does critical monitoring, then either buy Zabbix support, go to the Zabbix IRC channel or post to the forums. The forums are community supported - not Zabbix supported.

          The chances of you getting an immediate answer here would be rather slim anyway.

          Comment

          • Jimmy845
            Junior Member
            • May 2015
            • 1

            #6
            Its Really helpful and east to use

            But it is really helpful and easy to use.

            Comment

            Working...