Alert Host condition, not working or useless?

[Valerie]

Hi,

Just realised that even though we use combine the 2 following conditions in Alert configuration:

Trigger Host = "HAL"
Trigger value = "ON"

the specified receiver will receive all alerts for VALUE="ON", not only those for the it's host.

This is bad, has we want to notice specified user only when their specific machine raise a trigger/alert.

I am using version 1.1 beta 5, is this solved in new version? Is their a workaround or something I am missing in alert configuration?

Thanks

[Alexei]

Are you sure you receive all notifications regardless of host name? It is the only action defined?

[Valerie]

Hi Alexei,

I am pretty sure the user received all email, for all triggers from all host...At least, i am 100% sure he did not only receive email regarding the host specified in the action configuration.
Plus, this is a sample email I received.

Components: Processor load is high on wd2016472: ON

--- 
Trigger value = "ON"
Host = "aquila"

This email comes from the action with only the 2 conditions listed...


Maybe this has something to do with this bug :
When i add a Host trigger condition, and then select it with the checkbox and click on "delete selected", it does not disapear from the Conditions list...

[Valerie]

We've got a test machine on wich run Zabbix 1.1Beta6. I tried the same conditions as explained above and it seems to have the exact same behavior.
The action sent is :

Basics: wd2019339 is unreachable: ON
---------------
Conditions
Host = "aquila"
Trigger value = "ON"

I believe actions with host="someHost" should only be sent when THAT host raise a trigger right? But that is not the case nor in 1.1b5 or 1.1b6

Any help or approval/denied on this case would be greatly appreciated.

[maglarr99]

Same here....

I am getting the same here. I setup an action so my IT Manager only get an email on our switches and no matter what trigger fires, he gets an email, not just for the switches.

[rares]

Maybe this is the problem(in actions.c)

@@ -422,6 +422,7 @@ static int  check_action_condition(DB_TRI
                result = DBselect(sql);
                for(i=0;i<DBnum_rows(result);i++)
                {
+                       ret = FAIL;
                        if(condition->operator == CONDITION_OPERATOR_EQUAL)
                        {       
                                if(atoi(condition->value) == atoi(DBget_field(result,i,0)))

Probably you should wait for someone that look for more then 10 minutes to the zabbix code to advice.

take care

[Valerie]

Alexei,
Is there a fix for this comming? Should I configure the action, one per trigger instead of using Maccros?