Ad Widget

Collapse

Host availability false-positive

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • BSouza
    Junior Member
    • Dec 2006
    • 5

    #1

    Host availability false-positive

    I have a network where I need to monitor hosts by using Zabbix Agent, SNMP Agent and Simple Check together. For example:

    Host1
    |
    |--- Zabbix Agent -> Verifying filesystem's mount
    |
    |--- Simple Check -> SSH status


    Host2
    |
    |--- SNMP Agent -> Interface physical status
    |
    |--- Simple Check -> ICMP Ping

    The problem: if Zabbix Agent or SNMP Agent goes down, the host status is set to unavailable and all the other checks (Simple Checks, for example) also stops, assuming that the host is really unavailable.
    But it's not necessarily true. Another check, like Simple Check, at this moment could still determine host availability.
    The truth, in that case, is that Zabbix Agent is unavailable, and not the host and, with the present logic, we have a false-positive.

    Someone has an idea that will solve my problem? Someone has the same problem? Is that a real problem, or am I trying to do by the wrong way?

    I have suggestions but they involve Zabbix Server modification:

    - Create a host expression (like trigger expression) that will determine host availability;
    - Permit that, with Zabbix Agent and/or Simple Check and/or SNMP Agent checks mixed, case one of them stops, just checks of the same type also stop.
    Last edited by BSouza; 19-01-2007, 03:07. Reason: Subscribe
  • bbrendon
    Senior Member
    • Sep 2005
    • 870

    #2
    My first question is, why not fix your agents? That would solve all your problems.

    What you're asking is already built into the product. You can have trigger and alert dependencies.

    Your false positive issues are really not that bad. I've seen much bigger issues with false positives.
    Last edited by bbrendon; 19-01-2007, 04:25.
    Unofficial Zabbix Expert
    Blog, Corporate Site

    Comment

    • BSouza
      Junior Member
      • Dec 2006
      • 5

      #3
      My first question is, why not fix your agents? That would solve all your problems.
      I will never be 100% sure of Zabbix Agent availability... Because of this I need a network monitoring tool.

      What you're asking is already built into the product. You can have trigger and alert dependencies.
      Trigger dependency is another problem for me (I'm running version 1.1.3), but I will verify another time.

      Your false positive issues are really not that bad. I've seen much bigger issues with false positives.
      Finally, I have to mitigate false-positives to assure Zabbix reliability.
      Last edited by BSouza; 19-01-2007, 12:48. Reason: Better formating

      Comment

      • BSouza
        Junior Member
        • Dec 2006
        • 5

        #4
        Any help about that problem?

        Comment

        Working...